RERELEASE: Equal Rites by Terry Pratchett


Episode 249
Release Date: November 18, 2026
Your hosts revisit their Journey to the Center of the Discworld with this rerelease of their discussion of Equal Rites by Terry Pratchett. They talk about early versions of recurring characters, how great Granny Weatherwax is, and the difference between a wizard and a witch.
Thanks to the following musicians for the use of their songs:
- Amarià for the use of “Sérénade à Notre Dame de Paris”
- Josh Woodward for the use of “Electric Sunrise”
Licensed under Creative Commons: By Attribution 4.0 License
Episode Transcript*
*this transcript is generated by Descript, please excuse the mess.
Lilly 0:04
Hello and welcome to Fiction Fans, a podcast where we read books and other words too. I'm Lily,
Sara 0:10
and I'm Sarah, and today we're re-releasing an episode that we recorded when we first started the podcast.
Lilly 0:16
so we won't be doing our quick five minute intro this time.
Sara 0:20
During the first year of the podcast, we combined two book conversations into each episode along with some related segments like Pet Peeve Corner, and words are weird.
Lilly 0:30
We decided to republish those conversations as separate episodes to give those books a better chance to shine.
Sara 0:36
These have been slightly remastered, but you can still enjoy our Peak 2021 Microphone Technology.
Lilly 0:43
If you want to listen to the original double feature, these are episodes two through 23 in our podcast feed.
Sara 0:50
And as always, come disagree with us.
Lilly 0:53
It's that time again, time for us to take another step on our journey to the center of the Discworld
Sara 1:02
Dun dun dun
Lilly 1:05
Actually, we already played the music, but thank you.
Sara 1:10
You're welcome. I just wanted to contribute something.
Lilly 1:13
You can contribute everything. You can contribute the title of the book for this episode
Sara 1:19
Yes, so for this journey to the center of the Discworld, we read Equal Rites, which is the third book in the Discworld series, published in 1987. The, the publication page
Lilly 1:31
Of course, written by Sir Terry Pratchett.
Sara 1:34
Oh, did I not mention that? I did not mention that.
Lilly 1:36
Does it go without saying? Hopefully. Maybe
Sara 1:40
I feel, I feel like if you've made it this far, you have presumably listened to us talk about, Journey to the Center of the Discworld before, and s- so would know that Discworld is Terry Pratchett. I don't know.
Lilly 1:53
or read the episode description
Sara 1:55
Or read the episode description. That, too
Lilly 1:57
But we're, we're now getting into what we consider more legit Discworld. Because the first two books are definitely Pratchett getting, finding his sea legs, so to speak
Sara 2:13
Yeah, this, this is more, more like Discworld's final form. Like, there, there are still some bits of it that are not, where, where he's still experimenting.
Lilly 2:25
Mm-hmm.
Sara 2:26
But it's much closer to what you would expect from a traditional, quote-unquote, Discworld novel
Lilly 2:35
It feels wrong to refer to Discworld as traditional
Sara 2:39
It does, it does somehow
Lilly 2:41
How many books are in this series as a whole? We keep talking about Discworld, but I don't think we've actually mentioned how long it is
Sara 2:47
I think it's, um, I wanna say it's 41 books
Lilly 2:51
Damn, I gotta stop making fun of Wheel of Time.
Sara 2:54
Yeah, 41 novels, the internet tells me
Lilly 2:58
They mostly stand alone though. Discworld
Sara 3:01
they, yes, they are standalone books. I mean, there's, there's pr- character progression, but I think for the most part, if you pick one up, it doesn't matter if you've picked up the previous book. And they're also much shorter than the Wheel of Time books
Lilly 3:13
That's true. And that's extra true for Equal Rites because it has almost nothing to do with the first two books other than being set in the same world
Sara 3:24
Yeah, I don't think that there are any characters in the first two books who appear in this. It does involve wizards, but even the wizards are different
Lilly 3:35
Y- so the location is the same. You have the Unseen University, which is the wizarding school. But other than that, th- that's about the only overlap
Sara 3:46
Yeah. The, the math is the same
Lilly 3:49
I don't think the character Death even showed up. He's sort of implied at the beginning, but you don't actually hear any dialogue from him, which is very strange
Sara 3:59
Uh, no, you, you do, you do hear dialogue from
Lilly 4:01
Okay, good, good.
Sara 4:02
Yeah
Lilly 4:03
Otherwise, is it even Discworld?
Sara 4:06
I guess Death as a character, is the overlap. But beyond him, and he's only in the beginning for a very small portion of it
Lilly 4:15
Now, the premise of this book as you might have gleaned from the title, delves into the conflict between witches and wizards, or witchcraft and wizardry, I should say. The conflict is not so much between the people as it is between the concepts of the two. Or at least that's what's on the page. Pratchett is using these two sort of conflicting magical philosophies to really look, look at the, the construct of the patriarchy, the artificial barriers presented to women trying to interact with traditionally male spaces. I could go on.
Sara 5:00
Yeah, I mean, as, as expected from, from a Pratchett novel
Lilly 5:05
He does this by introducing a woman who is destined for wizardry, and he does that in sort of a... He, he, he plays on the shortcomings of tradition in a really cool way, I think
Sara 5:21
Yeah. So it start, the book starts out with a wizard going in search of someone that he can, who, who, a wizard who knows that he's dying, going in search of someone that he can leave his magic to. And he, he goes to a house that is about to have an eighth son of an eighth son, and he says, "Okay, I'm gonna leave my magic to your son," and then he dies. And then right as that happens, it's discovered that, oh, whoops, it's actually an eighth daughter. And so then you get into, well, she has wizard magic, but she's a woman, or she's a girl, and girls don't learn wizardry. That's specifically a, a male job, or a, male magic. And so the, the book is an exploration of her attempts to learn wizardry, and Pratchett's commentary on this sort of arbitrary divide between the sexes
Lilly 6:25
Okay. Why should you read this book, Sarah?
Sara 6:28
you should read this book because it has Granny Weatherwax in it
Lilly 6:34
Oh, you should read every book with Granny Weatherwax in it
Sara 6:37
Yes. See, that's, that's why it's part of my argument for why you should read this book. But it is a fun exploration of,
Lilly 6:46
It uses magic as a metaphor, of course, unless you're hiding something from me, Sarah. But it, it uses that to explore the false concept that the genders have different capabilities.
Sara 7:01
Yeah
Lilly 7:02
Maybe a better question is, should you read this book first? Because I think our answer is going to be read all of Discworld. Duh. Done. But should this be your first Discworld novel?
Sara 7:15
I don't think this should be your first Discworld novel. I think it's okay if it is. It's certainly a better entry point into Discworld than the first two books. But I think that he's still finding his feet, and even though it's much closer in form to what Discworld will be, it's still better to start where he has a better grasp on the characters and what he wants from the series
Lilly 7:43
I would agree. This is definitely one of those that where when you know where he's going with it, you sort of bring that to this book
Sara 7:53
Mm-hmm This episode of Fiction Fans is brought to you by Tisha.
Lilly 8:01
That's our zine. Each issue has a different theme that celebrates genre and genre blending in a new way.
Sara 8:08
PDF, and Epub versions can be purchased on our website and Patreon, supporters of all levels get free digital copies.
Lilly 8:16
You can find all of the issues and more at patreon.com/fiction fans pod. Thank you for all of your support.
Sara 8:24
The remainder of this episode contains spoilers.
Lilly 8:30
I wanted to put a spoiler break there because I wanted to say something I'm really glad Pratchett didn't do, but that's kind of a spoiler if he didn't do something, right?
Sara 8:41
Yeah, I think, I think that would constitute as a spoiler.
Lilly 8:45
I'm really glad he didn't just rehash that old, "So she dressed up as a boy," thing. I think that could have been a really obvious way to go
Sara 8:56
Yeah. It feels like a fresh take on it because she goes to the university as this 11-year-old girl who's insistent that she learn magic, and she's told no. And Granny Weatherwax, who is the witch for her village, who is with her on this trip into the city, into Ankh-Morpork, finds an in for her, but it means that she goes to the Unseen University as, like, a serve- Like, she goes, she goes there, she gets in as a maid, yeah. She's not actually there as a student
Lilly 9:35
I, I think the "so she dressed up as a boy" is over- not overdone, but has been done
Sara 9:42
It has been done. Y- y- you don't, there's, there's not a lot of things to say about that
Lilly 9:47
And I think there's something else to be said in this is a story about a girl who wants to be a girl wizard.
Sara 9:59
Mm-hmm.
Lilly 9:59
That's, you know, that's her whole goal. it's not, you know, pretend to be something you aren't, change who you are in order to get this power. It's you can be a girl and be a wizard
Sara 10:12
That's a very good point, actually
Lilly 10:13
it has a whole different sort of impact to it
Sara 10:17
Yeah, because if she was gonna change who she was, I, I feel like the story goes she would just learn witchcraft. But ultimately, it's shown that, that her, I don't wanna say type of magic, but, her method of using magic is pretty incompatible with witchcraft. That's just not the way that she works
Lilly 10:41
Mm-hmm. Although a lot of the things she does is also not typical wizardry, which is sort of brought up in the book. She's doing things that wizards don't think are possible just because no one has told her they're impossible
Sara 10:54
Exactly. there's a really good quote, about that. "It is well known that a vital ingredient of success is not knowing that you're, that what you're attempting can't be done. A person ignorant of the possibility of failure can be a half brick in the path of the bicycle of history."
Lilly 11:09
And I think that's such a great hint early on. We, we sort of discussed this a little bit out of the podcast, but I feel like Where this book ends is that witchcraft and wizardry aren't actually different magics themselves, because that's a refrain through the whole book. All of the characters are saying witchcraft is women's magic and wizardry is men's magic. But at the end, you, you do sort of see where they overlap, and it leaves you off thinking, or leave- left me thinking they're probably not different magics, they're just different ways of approaching it
Sara 11:51
Yeah, they have, they have the same source but, but different ways of going at it
Lilly 11:56
Right. And that made me think of the concept that women aren't actually more emotionally intelligent than men, they're just socialized to be.
Sara 12:06
Mm-hmm.
Lilly 12:06
And so witchcraft isn't women's magic, witchcraft is just the type of magic that women are socialized to perform. we do see a sort of battle of magic near the end between Granny Weatherwax, the main character's guardian, and the head of the wizarding school. W- Granny does eventually charge in there and demands to be taken seriously. This is near the climax of the book. She doesn't do that to get the main character into the school, she does it to save the world, because sometimes things are necessary and sometimes you can find a way around it, which is sort of her whole point.
Sara 12:44
Ja
Lilly 12:46
But by then she, she charges in there and they, they go at each other using the same stuff. Like, they're transfiguring each other, and, like, that's the same magic.
Sara 13:01
I, I think, I think, I, well, two things. I think you have a point there, but also my interpretation of that scene was so different because I was, when I, when I read it, I was thinking, "Oh, this is exactly like The, Sword in the Stone." So I was, I was feeling more the reference that it was making to, like the callback it was making to other work, and not so much the reference that it was making to, like the thematic reference that it was making. Because it is exactly like, the scene between Merlin and Madame Mim in The Sword in the Stone.
Lilly 13:38
Well, that's excellent and something I did not get at all.
Sara 13:41
Yeah. I had to do a, I had to do a lot of Googling because it's been ages since I've read The Sword in the Stone, and even longer since I've seen the movie, and I couldn't remember who Merlin was battling, and it was very hard to find that information
Lilly 13:56
I do wanna talk a little bit about Granny Weatherwax for a second. She is, A, incredible and amazing, and I love her
Sara 14:06
I think Granny is actually my favorite, probably my, if I had, had to rank characters in Discworld, which please don't make me do, 'cause that would be cruel, I think Granny would be my number one
Lilly 14:18
She has this, someone calls her Mrs. or, or Mum or Mom or, you know, Mother Weatherwax or sm- something like that, and every time she corrects them and says, "I'm no one's mother." and then someone asks who she's granny of, and the main character says, "Well, sort of everyone, I suppose."
Sara 14:39
I really like Granny because it's, I feel it's very rare that you find a character who plays this version, like plays this, this part of an old lady, like Crone in the trio of witches, which doesn't show up in this particular book, but we'll, we'll get there eventually. But that's kind of her choice. Like, there's a good quote where Esk says, "Didn't you wanna get married?" It was Granny's time to think. "Never got around to it," she said at last. "Too many other things to do, you see." And it's nice to see someone who just kind of doesn't care about marriage and, and relationships
Lilly 15:19
Right. She's not making a big deal out of
Sara 15:21
Yeah. It just,
Lilly 15:21
It's not dramatic.
Sara 15:23
Yeah. She's not, she's not bitter about it
Lilly 15:26
I think you and I have discussed this off the air, but the witches in Discworld are really reminiscent of... I think it's an agreed upon thing that witches, the real women were just medicine women who, you know, gave herbal cures for things like maybe birth control, which is not explicitly stated in the book, but that's because the main character, Esk, is young, and so they don't wanna actually spell it out in front of her. But it's clearly,
Sara 16:00
it's, it's heavily implied.
Lilly 16:02
it's very heavily
Sara 16:03
Yeah. Like, it's, it's there in the text. It's just they don't say those words, but it's there.
Lilly 16:09
And this isn't exactly on topic, but I just really love the connection between that old witch story that a young woman goes off into the forest and trades her firstborn child for some kind of future, s- some, some goal, some personal goal, and how closely that mirrors the concept of abortion. And these were probably stories created to vilify these medicine women who were just performing, you know, a medical procedure. But that idea of trading a, a firstborn child for a future, it just, like, really clicks, I think.
Sara 16:52
Mm-hmm.
Lilly 16:52
And that's I think that's very neat, and not exactly on topic, but the witches in Discworld do the same thing, so I'm gonna say it counts.
Sara 17:03
provide those services
Lilly 17:05
And then also, you know, magical Viagra and whatever else.
Sara 17:10
Except, except that most of it is just pretend.
Lilly 17:14
Or herbal.
Sara 17:15
or
Lilly 17:15
not necessarily pretend, yeah
Sara 17:17
But, but there's...
Lilly 17:19
Headology?
Sara 17:20
Yeah, there's, there's hedology. Like, yeah, Granny has a quote about people will believe it if you make a production out of it. So sh- she says, "Listen," said Granny, "if you give someone a bottle of red jollop for their wind, it may work, right? But if you want it to work for sure, then you let their mind make it work for them. Tell them it's moonbeams bottled in fairy wine or something."
Lilly 17:41
Which is also a real thing. I mean, we all know that placebos have a whatever percent success rate,
Sara 17:48
Uh-huh
Lilly 17:49
10 or something? I don't know.
Sara 17:51
They ha- they have a success rate.
Lilly 17:53
But there are studies that show if the placebo is perceived to be expensive or exclusive, the success rate goes up.
Sara 18:02
I mean, I feel like that's the, that's the same way that people get you to buy things. They, they tell you that it's exclusive or you're getting a great deal, even if it's i- an imaginary deal
Lilly 18:13
Right. But like people actually say like, yes, they had a, a better reduction in pain or whatever if they paid a lot of money for it
Sara 18:23
There's a mental component
Lilly 18:25
There is absolutely a mental component just in, in, I'm gonna use the word wellness. Just everyone know I'm rolling my eyes at the same time. But there is, and the, the, which, witches in this book tap into that very successfully
Sara 18:47
And Granny in particular.
Lilly 18:49
Oh, she's, she's a master. She's incredible.
Sara 18:51
Yeah
Lilly 18:52
She's also one of the few characters in this book that stay the same. Not, not the same, but
Sara 19:00
Her, her character gets refined as Terry
Lilly 19:04
in later
Sara 19:04
writes more Discworld, yeah, in, in later books. But there are a lot, well, not a lot, there, there are two kind of what I would call, like, proto characters in this book, where you can see there are direct parallels between them and characters who show up as side characters in later books
Lilly 19:24
parallels or almost direct carbon copies with a different name.
Sara 19:28
Yeah.
Lilly 19:29
They are, like, that's underselling it
Sara 19:32
I, I mean, I, I think one of them is more of a parallel, like Simon, who is similar to Esk going into the Unseen University to study wizardry, except that he's a man, so he actually gets in.
Lilly 19:48
Kid, he's a
Sara 19:49
kid, he's a kid. He's like 14 or something,
Lilly 19:52
But male, yes.
Sara 19:53
but male, so he gets in. But there are parallels between him and a, I wanna say, like, graduate studies wi- wizard in later books, Ponder Stibbons, and that's more... That's not a direct, like, one-to-one relationship, between those two characters, I don't think.
Lilly 20:14
They're just, they're a young, a young wizard or student who is approaching magic from a much more STEM-based approach
Sara 20:26
Yes
Lilly 20:27
the old stodgy sort of, "We're wizards and we're gonna sit around smoking pipes."
Sara 20:33
They have a more scientific approach to magic as opposed to the smoke and mirrors approach of the traditional wizards at the university. But the character of Kutangle, however his name is pronounced, who is the arch chancellor of the Unseen University in this book, is, as you said, basically a, a one-to-one
Lilly 20:59
Prototype?
Sara 20:59
carbon copy, yeah, prototype of Arch Chancer- Arch Chancellor Ridcully, who is the arch chancellor later on in the series. They're both arch chancellor of the Unseen University. They're both from the same place, the Ram tops
Lilly 21:18
They both have a crush on Granny, which who doesn't? But also
Sara 21:23
Yeah. So he's, he's very clearly proto-Ridcully. Like, Pratchett clearly has an idea for this character that he wants to explore, and he ends up doing it through... I mean, he, he changes some aspects of, of Cutangle, you know, the name and things like that, but
Lilly 21:41
It really makes me wonder why he changed his name but not Granny
Sara 21:47
Ridcully sounds better
Lilly 21:49
Is, y- uh, maybe that's it. Maybe the character only
Sara 21:52
that, yeah.
Lilly 21:53
because Cutangle is a bad name.
Sara 21:55
Yeah. And I think that Ridcully gets some minor character changes, like he's...
Lilly 22:02
Granny Weatherwax.
Sara 22:04
does Granny Weatherwax, it's
Lilly 22:05
So if he's gonna keep Granny, why... But maybe it was just the name. I like, I really think maybe that was it.
Sara 22:12
It m- I, that's the only, that's the only reason I can think of given that the character history and background and profession is so exactly the same.
Lilly 22:26
You know whose name doesn't change?
Sara 22:28
Because they don't have one?
Lilly 22:30
Well, he has a title, The Librarian
Sara 22:35
The librarian is wonderful. The librarian is also a favorite character of mine
Lilly 22:40
He's incredible. So during the shenanigans in the first two books, there's a lot of chaos happening, and at one point the librarian at the Unseen University gets turned into an orangutan.
Sara 22:53
the first book.
Lilly 22:55
It's the first one?
Sara 22:56
Yeah, this, this happens in the first book.
Lilly 22:59
they're the same. They're like just one book in my head
Sara 23:03
I, a- actually, I honestly thought for the longest time that it happened in, the book that I think is next in the series. And so when we were, were rereading, uh, A Color of Magic, I was a little bit astonished to find that the librarian undergoes that change then.
Lilly 23:20
From the very beginning, death and the librarian are the only two constants.
Sara 23:25
Not taxes.
Lilly 23:26
Not taxes. The librarian is much better
Sara 23:29
The librarian is much better
Lilly 23:31
And in this book he's introduced they don't go into how it happens. You could read The Color of Magic if you want to find out. But they do say something like, "Any attempts to change him back have been thwarted because the librarian much prefers it this way," which is just so e- excellent
Sara 23:50
I don't have anything to add except that the librarian is an excellent character
Lilly 23:54
He only says "Oook," but everyone can understand exactly what he means, which is so charming. And he likes having extra long arms 'cause he can reach the books better.
Sara 24:05
A very fair point
Lilly 24:07
He's the Librarian. It was just a crying shame that we didn't bring him up earlier when this actually happened to him, but now we're actually seeing him as the custodian of these incredibly dangerous magical tomes, and he's just a happy little orangutan swinging around, eating bananas. He's very sweet. So our only common characters through all of Discworld are the Librarian and, of course, as we mentioned before, Death, who has an excellent quote at the beginning that you pulled out that I think would be a really nice, nice thing to end this on
Sara 24:48
Yeah. So Death has come for this wizard who kicks off all of the, the events of this book, and he's realized too late that Esk is a girl, and so he's left his magic to a girl and not an eighth son of an eighth son, as he thought he was. And he says, "But she's going to have a lot of problems." And Death responds, "That's what life is all about. So I'm told. I wouldn't know, of course."
Lilly 25:15
You tell 'em, Death. You tell 'em
Sara 25:21
Thank you so much for listening to this episode of Fiction Fans.
Lilly 25:25
Come disagree with us! We're on BlueSky and Instagram at fictionfanspod. You can also email us at fictionfanspod at gmail. com or leave a comment on YouTube.
Sara 25:37
If you enjoyed the episode, please rate and review on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, and follow us wherever your podcasts live.
Lilly 25:44
We also have a Patreon, where you can support us and find exclusive episodes and a lot of other nonsense.
Sara 25:51
Thanks again for listening, and may your villains always be defeated. Bye!


